Perl 5 to Perl 6 Rewrite

My coworker Wes asked me if there could be a nice refactor for the following function which checks CAS Numbers to ensure their validity. After struggling for 30 minutes I gave up trying to make it a little bit nicer with reduce.

sub cas_old {
  my $cas = shift;
  if ($cas =~ /\d{1,8}-\d\d-\d/) {
    my @ary = grep { $_ ne '-' } split(//, $cas);
    my $check = pop @ary;
    my $count = @ary;
    my $sum;
    for (@ary){
      $sum += $_ * $count--;
    return $sum % 10 == $check;

Let’s take a look at this and figure it out. The crunchy bit is the for loop, so I’ll go through that. Basically we are summing each item times a weight that is inversely proportional to it’s location in the list. Or to be more explicit, let’s do an example on the board (7732-18-5.) 5 is the check digit.

$_ $count $_ * $count $sum
7 6 42 42
7 5 35 77
3 4 12 89
2 3 6 95
1 2 2 97
8 1 8 105

So basically we are making a special summation. The thing that’s unusual is that we have a decrementing counter along with it. If I had the control structure which I am about to show you in my mind already the solution might have jumped out sooner.

So I asked about it in #perl6 and it turns out there is a very nice Perl 6 version. It takes advantage of the mystical hyperoperator (>>infix op<<); that is, it takes two lists and performs an operation on each element together. Think SIMD. It also uses reduce ([infix op]) which I have mentioned before. Check it out!

sub cas(Str $cas) {
    if $cas ~~ /(\d ** 1..8)\-(\d\d)\-(\d)/ {
        my @digits = $0~$1.split '';
        my $check = $2;
        return ([+] @digits.reverse
           ([email protected])) % 10 == $check;
    return Bool::False;

This does the same thing as above. Or to put it in English, we take our digits, reverse them, and then multiply each digit (hyperoperator, >>*<<) by the respective integer in the other list, that is, 1 to the size of the list. We then sum (reduce, [+]) that new list, and get the modulus 10 of it.

Very elegant, no?

Update: Turns out there is also a very elegant version in p5, according to mst. Check it out!

sub cas_old {
  use List::Util 'sum';
  my $cas = shift;
  if ($cas =~ /(\d{1,8})-(\d\d)-(\d)/) {
    my @digits = split(//, $1.$2);
    my $count = @digits;
    my $check = $3;
    return (sum map $_ * $digits[-$_],
       1 .. $count) % 10 == $check;

It’s very similar to the p6 version, just using fewer generalized operators, so you should be able to follow it fairly well.

Posted Fri, May 15, 2009

Receive Blog Posts in Your Email