Scalablity, Reliability, and Performance at ZipRecruiter
I did a talk at YAPC this year, and while I am really proud of it and think that it went well, I think it could have gone better. This post is a retrospective on what I could do better next time.
The overall structure of the talk was the general (starting with no silver bullet) to the specific (ending with a discussion of our bakeoff and what we will tackle next.) It might have made more sense to interleave the two, but it’s hard to say.
I wish I had emphasized the no silver bullet point harder, but I don’t want people to think that this is impossible, just that there are no prescriptions that will work for everyone.
Now on to the specifics.
🔗 Capacity Caches
I didn’t define Capacity Caches well enough in the talk. Afterwards I realized this and I should not have used a no-true-scottsman to define the term, but so it goes. For the record, I would define a capacity cache today as a cache that allows you to serve more users, as opposed to a (latency) cache that allows you to serve the same number of users faster. The tricky bit is that the latter can silently transform into the former if you don’t keep an eye on it.
Someone (Henry Vanstyn I think) asked if we had had an outage due to this and while we had not, I didn’t realize till after the fact that we did have a slowdown. I think I should have had examples prepared.
🔗 Timeouts / Reapers
I felt like this section of the talk went really well. I am especially pleased with the “wow” moment from when I showed the reaper report for the S3 outage. The one major improvement I would make to this, and my main regret for the talk as a whole, was that while the application of this advice to ZR, Booking, and maybe GSG is clear, it is not clear how it can apply to smaller applications.
I think I should have explained that a reaper could be made to work even in a single server situation and indeed in that situation may even be more critical. I did in fact explain this to some friends when we discussed how my talk went, but that idea should come with the talk.
The other nuance that I didn’t explain, which only barely belongs in the talk, is that while reaping and timeouts sound scary, ultimately you are foolish not to implement a really generous one at the minimum, because the client will eventually time out. So while you may think “but the user has been waiting five minutes!” really their browser probably gave up two minutes ago and you are just wasting resources.
There were a lot of details I didn’t go into related to Aurora, and I think that’s ok. As I said at the beginning of the talk, I didn’t want to dive into a bunch of detail no one cares about. I left out the cruel irony about how Aurora is implemented in such a way that at it’s heart is a capacity cache that is insufficient for ZipRecruiter. I maybe shouldn’t have left that out.
I wish I had blogged about the splitter ahead of time, if only to be sure to have lots of details to refer to like I can for some of the other topics. I am planning on blogging about it soon anyway if only so that people can learn more later.
I also somewhat wish that I mentioned that the splitter sometimes feels like a capacity cache in that bugs are introduced and we don’t notice very easily. I’ll save in depth discussion of that for the blog post.
🔗 Table Refactor
This information I think was mostly useful in demonstrating the different values of a small and large application. With a small team and stack that must be on one or two servers, using lots of different software is a liability, but in our case depending on a single service for lots of different workloads is also a liability.
🔗 Performance Monitoring
I don’t feel thrilled about this section of the talk even though I am really proud of this monitoring. I think I should have, just like with the reaper, explained how a small application could implement this without all of the incredible overhead of ElasticSearch, fluentd, and Kibana. In short: if you were to simply log json and then build a small frontend, or even just use jq, you could have a lot of the benefits that we got with almost none of the pain.
🔗 Memory Work
I thought that I was clear enough here, but afterwards Jim Keenan approached me and asked if I would be willing to clarify our issues to the Perl maintainers in the hopes that the issues could be resolved or even just improved. I will do that and to some extent wish I had reached out sooner. We’ll see what happens though; I am hopeful but do not have any expectations.
🔗 nginx vs Apache
There’s not a lot to say here. I thought this went perfectly fine and was applicable to almost everyone there.
I didn’t have much time to prepare for this slide, and in fact only added it shortly before the talk because the bakeoff concluded while I was travelling to YAPC. I should have included some of the statistics from the actual bakeoff but really, the point is not what was faster, but what engineers could make fast on their own.
I am more proud of this talk than any of the others I have done. Aside from my AWS IAM talk which I only gave to LA.pm it is one of the only talks I’ve done in recent memory that is not only cross-language but also not about a specific library. While it could have been improved greatly with some of the ideas above, I still think it went really well.
If you want to be a better big systems engineer (like the stuff above) I recommend the Site Reliability Engineering book by “Google.” Some parts of it are frustrating in the almost posturing academic style, but there are some great gems that make it worth the slog.
Not specifically related to this talk but related to my job I recently picked up
The Linux Programming Interface.
I felt like I needed to fill in some blanks, and this book looked to be the best
tool for the job. My only complaint is that a lot has happened in the
intervening seven years and I would have liked to get an improved foundation for
namespaces; neither appear in the index.
I wish I had some resources to recommend regarding preparing and delivering talks. I have been doing it for over a decade so my advice is likely to be as unhelpful as a FAQ written by a veteran user. If there is a resource I should know about, please point me to it; I am happy to improve.Posted Wed, Jul 5, 2017